INTERVIEW: NINA ARCHER ON MIXED SIGNALS, BIG FEELINGS, AND FINDING HER OWN VOICE AT 17
At 17, Kansas City singer-songwriter Nina Archer already has the self-awareness of a seasoned lyricist and the instincts of an artist who knows exactly what she wants to sound like. Following her September debut, “Homecoming,” she steps into a more playful style on her new single, “mixed signals,” a flirtatious pop track that examines the frustrating push-and-pull of inconsistent affection. Co-produced by Jeffery David and Brandon Paddock, the song pairs early-2000s-inspired rhythms with lyrics perceptive enough to reference dopamine surges and anxious attachment.
Join us in this conversation with her, where she opens up about standing her ground as the youngest person in the studio, why writing lyrics about push-pull dynamics hits differently than living them, and how she’s learning to balance emotional honesty with having fun on stage.
You’re 17, your second single is coming out, and suddenly this dream you’ve had since you were little is becoming very real. Does it feel like you’re growing up alongside your music, or is music actually helping you figure out who you are?
Probably more of the latter. Naturally, my songwriting has developed, my taste has evolved, and my understanding of music has become more sophisticated. If anything, the process of putting music out has taught me a lot about what I like and dislike.
Let’s talk about “mixed signals.” That title alone says so much. Someone can make you feel like you’re the most important person in the world one minute and a complete stranger the next. What was happening in your head when you started writing this song? And is it about one specific experience, or a feeling you’ve recognized in different parts of your life?
The way it was written was very straightforward, but it’s definitely a broad concept I can relate to. I think conflicting messages is a thing nearly everyone has experienced in some capacity, and this song is about the frustration that comes from never really knowing where you stand with somebody. In my head, the song doesn’t really connect to a specific experience, but just the general feeling that comes with knowing someone that has you on a hook and makes you feel loved or disregarded depending on the day. It actually wasn’t about a romantic relationship, but I know that’s definitely one of the more relatable interpretations of the song.
There’s something almost addictive about mixed signals. Sometimes the less someone gives you, the harder you try to figure them out. Why do you think people get so attached to situations that leave them confused? And have you ever caught yourself knowing better but still wanting an answer?
I think people usually get so attached to those situations because, not to get too neuroscience-y, unpredictable rewards can sometimes be more compelling than stability. When someone’s getting inconsistent affection, the dopamine surges can make it feel good. People could also tolerate situations like that because of familiarity, childhood experiences, anxious attachment, or even cognitive dissonance. Even knowing this, I’ve experienced this because unfortunately there are some people you love too much to kick out of your life.
You’re a really interesting lyricist because you can take a complicated emotion and make it feel incredibly specific. What’s your favorite lyric in “mixed signals,” and what’s the story behind it? Is there a line that means something different to you now than it did when you first wrote it?
My favorite lyric I wrote is probably, “I think that you like me best with one foot out the door.” It sucks when someone’s favorite thing about you is when you’re gone. I like that “one foot out the door” expression because I feel like it sums up how someone wants you only when there’s the possibility of losing you. Especially when it's from a guy who feels entitled to ownership of you. The song’s vibe isn’t very mad though; it’s kind of still flirtatious in a way. “Up for the chase, then running away” is probably the line that is different for me now. When I pictured the imagery of that line in my head in the past I pictured a person running towards someone and then away. Now I kind of picture a tiger or lion or something. I guess it goes to show how my opinion about the push-pull dynamic has changed.
People are beginning to hear comparisons to Tate McRae and Ariana Grande, which is pretty exciting company. Ariana’s vocal ability is extraordinary, and Tate has built such a distinctive combination of music, movement and attitude. What do you admire about artists like them? And what do you think people will eventually recognize as something uniquely Nina Archer?
Comparison to THE Ariana Grande? Crazy work. Literally the best vocalist of the generation, maybe even all time (tied with Kelly Clarkson). I’m still dealing with stupid puberty and my body isn’t letting me mix yet, so the thing I most admire about Ariana is her legendary mix. She’s also my celeb look-alike, I’ve been told forever. And Tate? Probably the best dancing artist of the generation (tied with Adela). I envy her no-skip discography. It’s genuinely banger after banger. I also, in a perfect world, would lean kind of Timbaland drummy and early-2000s dancey. For me, I hope that, especially when I get to some deep-cut originals out, people will like the poetic-conversational balance in my songwriting, and I hope people will consider me a performer, and not just a singer.
You’ve been making records with Jeffery David, who’s worked with Echosmith, Gabriella Rose and Mat Kearney, and Brandon Paddock, who’s worked with Avril Lavigne and Set It Off. That’s a pretty incredible creative team to be working with at 17! What’s it actually like in the studio with those guys? Is it intense and serious, or is there a lot more laughing and experimenting than people would expect? Tell us something funny that happened while making “mixed signals.”
In the studio, there's obviously a lot of trial and error and experimenting. Brandon and Jeffery co-produced the record, and there's a lot of throwing ideas around, good and bad, until the song feels right.
Something funny about making "mixed signals" was that I don't think any of us realized just how picky I could be about my vocal takes! We'd think we had it, and I'd want to try something else. An absurd amount of time went by, and honestly, I probably could've kept going for hours! I'm just grateful I'm getting the chance to start my career.
Here’s something we’re really curious about. When you’re the youngest person in a studio full of experienced producers and songwriters, it would probably be easy to assume everyone else knows better. Have you had moments where you disagreed with Jeffery or Brandon about a lyric, a vocal, a sound or an arrangement and stood up for your own idea? How do you know when to trust your instincts and when to let somebody challenge you?
I think I have a pretty clear sense of my own taste, even beyond music, but I can be quite the doormat. My philosophy is to always let someone challenge me if they want to. Sometimes I give in, and sometimes I try to follow my vision, and my instincts are almost always on track with that. I don’t think that being younger means you should automatically defer to someone else. Experience means something, definitely, but nobody is going to understand what I want and what people my age want better than I will, and I eventually realized that. I love hearing other perspectives, but I’m also working on trying not to keep quiet in fear of being difficult, because I’ve done that a lot. We had a lot of back and forth in the studio, both writing and sound-wise, and it’s gone many different ways. There was a moment where I found it in my soul to cause a little disagreement. There’s this one song where I had an outro idea that I don’t think anyone was a fan of, but I asked if I could just roughly record it to see if it sounds good. We did that, and it changed minds. We even did it acoustic to see if it would fit, and it did. So we actually ended up deciding that was the best way to end the song. I think you should always let someone challenge you, but I would love to speak out about my instincts more often.
Your voice can do some pretty unbelievable things, but sometimes the most emotional vocal isn’t necessarily the biggest one. When you were recording “mixed signals,” how did you decide when to hold back and when to really let go? Was there a particular vocal moment where you surprised yourself?
This song was actually challenging in its own way vocally because it doesn’t have much dynamic contrast at all, so I was being choosy about finding the right tone for the whole song since there weren’t any huge vocal moments. Honestly, singing mellow stuff is harder for me than being expressive. It’s kind of like holding back the whole time, which is cool sometimes. I wouldn’t say there was a specific vocal surprise but I think this was surprising in the carefulness behind it.
We’re seeing a whole new side of you since your debut single “Homecoming,” and we’re not mad at it! The dancing, the confidence, the attitude! You seem to be having so much fun. How important is dancing to you, and how does it help you express a side of yourself that singing alone doesn’t?
Dancing is quite new to me, so I’m figuring out how I feel about it. I do think it adds a necessary dimension to performing in this age. It takes effort, but it feels very instinctive and in my body in a way singing doesn’t, which is nice to have. In some ways, I actually find it easier and lower pressure, and I’m looking forward to getting better at it!
You have this wonderful contrast between being a deep thinker and being a genuinely funny, playful teenager. Do you ever feel pressure to choose between being taken seriously as an artist and simply having fun? Can a pop star be intelligent, emotional, ridiculous, glamorous and completely herself all at once?
Yeah, I think so. I never feel pressure about “choosing” really. I’ve actually noticed lots of similar questions that like emphasizing the contrast. Everybody has different dimensions to them and it doesn’t have to be contrasting. I’m super multifaceted, which is good and bad. I’m like 50% on every single letter of the MBTI test. I feel like I can behave in literally every way, so “completely herself” is still up in the air for me. But I feel like artists are not usually looked at as either a serious artist or a fun one. It actually makes the lock-in when I get on stage that much better. I think being emotional or adult and being fun can and often co-exist.
“Homecoming” was about wanting to belong, and now “mixed signals” explores another complicated part of human connection. Is there a common thread running through your songwriting? Are you discovering that you keep returning to certain questions about people, love, identity or the way we treat each other?
Both of these started off as song titles, and in my head, were going to be ballads. We ended up clearly going the opposite direction, but yes, there is a common thread of feeling defeated by toxic relationships. I do often write on my own about the ways people treat each other, love, and identity. Ultimately, I think that my life circumstances have always made me interested in exploring my relationships with others, myself, and the world.
You’re still independent, you’re only 17, and you’ve already recorded music that people haven’t heard yet. Imagine someone discovers you today through “mixed signals,” starts following you, and five years from now gets to say, “I was there at the beginning.” What do you hope they discover about you along the way? And what kind of artist do you want to become without losing the girl you are right now?
I hope OG fans discover that they’re getting to know me more honestly and fully with time. I hope they realize I’m not just another person figuring out whether they want this or not. I’m serious, and I want to keep pushing myself. And I’ll be just as hungry in 5 years. I want to become an artist who is more confident in my own creative decisions. I don’t want my personality to change a lot, and I know it won’t, but I’m crossing my fingers that my life will, for the better.